I. I've read "Cathedral" so many times, with years between each reading. I've never read "A Small, Good Thing." WOW to reading these back to back. Which I did last night.
II. To me, the engine of these two stories is INTIMACY, an intimacy that has nothing to do with sexuality. More than one character in each story moves into intimacy with another, sliding from a grounding in their own buried aloneness, so buried they may not have fully known they possessed it until presented with the oppportunity (the story's occasion) to encounter the lonely mystery embedded in others: the blind man, the baker.
III. This slide is ennabled by exhaustion-- an exhaustion achieved through drinking, dope, or death.
IV. The collection these stories come from-- "The Art of the Short Story," edited by Dana Gioia and R.S. Gwynn-- includes a brief "craft note" from the author, tacked on after the story/stories. In his note, Carver says, "It's possible, in a poem or a short story, to write about commonplace things and objects using commonplace but precise language, and to endow those things-- a chair, a window curtain, a fork, a stone, a woman's earring-- with immense, even startling power." He goes on to say a similar thing regarding dialogue.
Is it useful to say that this startling power of precision is, in fact, INTIMACY?
When we write precisely, are we writing intimately?
60 Minutes on D&D, 1985
5 hours ago
I think you're onto something, Joe. The proximity of precision is intimately close. It may be that the choice to write using commonplace language is intimate -- it is anything but evasive. It requires the boldness of intimacy to use ordinary language when appropriate.
ReplyDeleteThose are my two favorite Carver stories. Think I'll have to break them out tomorrow and enjoy enjoy enjoy. Thanks, man.
ReplyDeleteStephen: I dig what you've set up here-- intimacy and evasiveness as opposites. It reframes my understanding of intimacy. Like you say: "boldness." Is there such a thing as "evasive intimacy?" That might be a neat spark to flare up a story or scene around.
ReplyDeleteThanks, David-- I agree 100%, man are those stories great. "A Small Good Thing" closed my throat right up. When the baker says, "Sit down, sit down" a half a dozen times? Phew.